Today, I''m going to be reviewing the repackage of their first album which contains some new songs that the original "The Shinee World" album didn't contain... Let's go! XD
Amigo
This song is... alright. Nothing screams amazing or unique to me about this track and it doesn't really showcase the SHINee flavour that is usually associated with them. It really is just a bog-standard club banger that happens to sell well because of the group that sings it.
The song just sounds like noise most of the time, the vocals are pretty poorly arranged and the concept is pretty much dead. The only saving grace would be that even though the vocals are poorly arranged, the actual vocals themselves are pretty darn good, but that's pretty a much a given with most idol groups.
If any other group were to be given this song, I'd like it a heck of a lot more, but it just doesn't fit Shinee well at all and it is a total waste of a title track, ESPECIALLY for a re-package...
My final verdict (5/10)
My lowest rating so far, and with good reason too...
Forever or Never
Thankfully the album picks up slightly with a downtempo song that perfectly encapsulates what Shinee is all about... Beautiful vocals, club-based elements and production value that screams of unique artistic creativity.
Where Amigo just barely ticked some of the boxes, this song ticked all of them and I am eternally glad for it!
The vocals are arranged a lot better here and the beat is perfect because it is minimal enough to give preference to the vocals but unique enough to leave an impression and remain with the theme. Jonghyun's vocals really shine here too (which is always a plus, as he is my SHINee bias...) and so do the other's voices when they all come together...
This is a good song! I think it just needed something extra to give it a bit more of a boost, just because it's downtempo doesn't mean that it has to be too repetitive or too much on the safe side...
If anything it felt more like a ballad than it did a downtempo song (trust me, there is a difference...) and because of that it loses points based on trying to stick to the theme, even though both ends justify the means of how you would achieve the conceptualization of the track.
Regardless, it's a good song, so it gets... (8/10)
It's unique enough to be in the higher parts of my really strange rating system! ^_^
Love Like Oxygen
Is this SHINee or Michael Jackson?
That was the first thought that ran through my mind when I heard this, it's a compliment don't worry! :)
I love this song! It's so 80's and so modern at the same time, it does justice to the vocals as well as gets your head nodding along like a narcoleptic at a Taylor Swift concert.
The production value here is so brilliant and professionally done and the vocals are arranged nicely with the track (it helps that the vocals are freaking great too). How on earth do you manage to capture that signature 80s Michael Jackson-esque sound, throw in some club synths and create such a good song!
This is fantastic! (8/10)
This is fantastic! (8/10)
Love Should Go On
This song is pretty damn good... The beat is nostalgic and familiar with a slight old-school RnB vibe that isn't too in your face. Let's just say it has enough 90's to give a sense of "I've heard this before" but modern enough to be unique to a group like this.
Which is a recurring theme throughout the album, no matter what song it is, the group always leaves their imprint and identity on each track. The rap is... alright, the vocals are very clean and well looked after, but I've not been able to find a rap from Minho (on this album) that has been outstanding or anything past mediocre at best.
The song by itself is really good and arranged well, the brass stabs are in the right place and accentuate the song as opposed to detracting from it but you'd have to really nitpick to find many things wrong with it.
Overall, this is not bad for filler! (8/10 )
The song by itself is really good and arranged well, the brass stabs are in the right place and accentuate the song as opposed to detracting from it but you'd have to really nitpick to find many things wrong with it.
Overall, this is not bad for filler! (8/10 )
Noona Neomu Yeppeo (Replay)
Noona neomu yeppeo~
This song is the sole reason why I love this album... Now don't get me wrong, the other songs are great, but this song is my ringtone for a reason.
This is arguably the favourite SHINee song for other idols and I can see why, the hook is addictive, the production is smoother than silk and the vocals are so beautifully layered that they literally feel like they melt into each other.
This song is so beautifully produced and handled that it rivals the production value of some of the bigger companies in the good 'ol USA, and they have some of the best producers and recording software known to mankind. Not to say that SM doesn't have access to some of the same equipment, but for what they had to work with (especially when this song was released in about 2008) it is a masterpiece.
I cannot find anything wrong with the song that wouldn't be a recurring theme with most of SHINee's music... (I'm looking at you Choi Minho) but even then it still isn't enough to detract from how great this song sounds, nor can it impact the success it had as a cult classic amongst Shawols. People might gush about songs like Lucifer, Sherlock or Ring Ding Dong being their greatest successes, but quite frankly Replay shines above all of them musically and arguably in production value too (because Lucifer was pretty well produced itself...).
Props to The Heavyweights and Yoo Young Jin for making this such a wonderful song, and props to SHINee themselves for having such wonderful voices!
(10/10)
Romantic
Jonghyun... Why must your voice make me melt like ice cream on a summer's day?
But in all seriousness, another well produced ballad from the SM Family that decides to sneak it's way onto an album and be completely underrated... This is another really good song!
It progresses slowly enough to be considered a ballad but fast enough to not leave me feeling bored, Key's voice isn't auto-tuned the heck out (I know it happened in Replay, but it was forgivable due to how good the entire song was). Onew's vocals are done justice here and Jonghyun... Well, I don't really need to say more, do I?
The production value is pretty neat too, nice and simple and only adds minute details to induce progression throughout so that the entire piece isn't too chaotic, the guitar is perfectly crafted and arranged as a layer with the drums, it's literally like the two instruments are singing a duet with each other, so I have to give props to the producer on that much.
The one problem here that I really cannot forgive this time, CHOI FUCKING MINHO!
I don't get it, in the other songs he doesn't seem to have as much of a problem with staying on beat with his raps, but here it was just awful and the worst part is that the producer (who I just praised for knowing what he's doing with the vocals) has to turn him all the freaking way down because even he realises how bad Minho's rapping is.
Thankfully, this habit of being the main rapper and sucking at rapping has changed and developed into being the main rapper and being slightly mediocre at rapping in the later years, but this needed to be addressed because it is so prominent and prevalent that it is really awful in this song. Unfortunately, it has to detract from my final ranking and it has to take a big chunk too, because it actually ruined the song for me, this song actually would've been (9/10) but instead...
It's (7/10)
Love's Way
NOT ANOTHER FREAKING BALLAD, I SWEAR TO--
Oh? This is actually nice!
Onew is being Onew. insertoverusedquestionhere O_O
The production value is something I'm going to praise highly, but I will get to that in a moment, because the producer needs to be hailed for knowing how to make people sound good.
But first things first, Minho sounds good here... What? O_O
Jonghyun isn't belting his lungs but still sounds amazing. What? O_O
Key isn't clearly auto-tuned. What? O_O
Taemin sounds pretty good here too. What? O_O
This is a song that I will praise highly because the idols sound excellent, the vocals are legit and layered perfectly, Minho's rap is good and Jonghyun only needs a few high notes in the entire song to give the fangirls (and yours truly) the goosebumps that he deserves to earn. Overall, the producer knew what he was doing when he tightened up this song.
Speaking of the producer... ALL HAIL THIS GUY!!!
This song is already more (10/10) than Replay and that's just simple due to the fact that they both tick all the boxes, but where Replay just about ticks all of the boxes, this song actually emboldens all the ticks and gives 'em a bit of graphic design as well. The kicks are punchy enough to make a statement but have enough bass to massage your ears, the snares are prominent but don't detract from the song, the synths are beautifully layered to give flavour to the vocals and are light enough to remain there without intruding on the melody of the song, nor the bass underneath.
Props to Alex Cantrall and Wheesung for writing a Minho rap that is decent! (10/10)
One For Me
It seems I can no longer get mad at SHINee ballads, as long as they are written by Wheesung and produced by Alex Cantrall! ^_^
I don't have much to say about this song that I haven't said about Love's Way, they are different songs and I still prefer Love's Way and even Replay to this song, but this song is alright in it's own aspect... But it feels way too much like filler for my liking.
Minho sounds awkward in this song as well (even if Jonghyun's falsetto is as cool as always, it still doesn't make up for it). Furthermore, as good as the vocals are, this song is just so forgettable that they might as well be singing gibberish because the track itself (no matter how well produced) is just boring.
Ah well, I can still appreciate it musically even though it doesn't really do much for me as an actual song.
(8/10)
Graze
Sigh... Another ballad?
I mean it's fine and all that these are well produced, but lambasting the listener with ballad after ballad is not doing favours for the album, unless they are marketed as a Ballad group, and even then you should really sell that with the title tracks and have some variation in terms of song placement.
If the songs sound too similar, it ruins the impact that the songs would've had if handled correctly, and this song is another forgettable track too, which just screams album filler to me.
It's not that it is a bad song, it's just a victim of being in the wrong place at the wrong place and being slightly too boring for my liking after listening too other songs just like it on the CD. However, the song itself has some merit, the vocals are handled well, I love the riffs and melodies coming from the acoustic guitar and the harmonies are legit. There are shades of various 90's groups in this song as well, so that's always good.
Unfortunately that's not enough to warrant any sense of... well, anything towards this song. That's the true kiss of death, if your listener doesn't really feel anything from the song, then no matter how well it fits the concept or the theme, nor how well produced it is, you have ultimately failed, and that is mostly the fault of whoever places the tracks.
If this song was after say, "Love Like Oxygen", then this song would be appreciated more, but honestly I'm put off by the sheer amount of ballads that are coming one after another (taking into account that I don't even like most ballads to begin with and I'm only able to appreciate them musically, unless they are spectacular) is really just not doing favours for anyone at this point in time.
The highlight would have to be Minho's rapping... What? O_O
That's both a testament to how well the rap was written (for Minho's standards) and how badly the song failed to make any sort of impact on me as a listener.
In short? (7/10)
Last Gift
This song slides because it's actually good enough to make some sort of impact on me. This song sounds like your typical ballad, but because of how perfectly crafted and layered the vocals are and the beautiful simplicity yet serenity of the track gives it a nice welcoming feel for a song.
Jonghyun is truly at his best in this song as well, the ad-libs are on point and never truly excessive, the harmonies are beautiful and I am getting such a strong Boys 2 Men vibe from this song...
WHICH IS ALWAYS A GOOD THING!!!
Furthermore, no Minho rap! (see above for my reaction to this)
Seriously I had to listen to the song three times, just to make sure that I wasn't hallucinating and that I just missed the "rap" bit or something.
The production value is truly great here, but it suffers from the same problem as all of the other ill-placed ballads, and in my book, that's a cardinal sin that they've just committed... Therefore the rating is lower than it should be.
Here it is --> (8/10)
Best Place
Did I click on the wrong video or something? Because this sounds like a weird mixture of Replay and Gee...
In all seriousness, that was my first reaction, hear the verses in Gee and then play this song. The drum beat from Replay should be recognizable, but if you need a refresher then that's always around too.
Anyway, onto the song itself, this song isn't exactly a ballad because I wouldn't consider Replay a ballad either, neither would I consider Obsession a ballad, but whatever...
The vocals are nice, so is the backing track and this is a nice song to bump out at a chill out lounge or a barbeque, but other than roasting some Tonkatsu along to Jonghyun's heavenly falsetto, there is not much reason for this song to be in there, and quite frankly it's more filler than Season 12 of Naruto. (Ba-dum-tssh)
Minho's "rapping" is still awful however and the issue of the song being ballad enough to be considered a ballad but yet not a ballad at the same time is enough to make downrate this song to hell...
Verdict? (7/10)
Hyeya
Four. No Minho Rap.
Ballads! They're everywhere! Seriously, I wonder what there's more of?
a) Zubats in Dark Cave
b) Power Level in Vegeta Scouter
c) BALLADS IN THIS FUCKING ALBUM!!
It shouldn't take a genius to figure out the answer to this question... So, why am I so happy?
One. It's Kim Jonghyun singing a solo ballad.
Two. It is a freaking masterpiece.
Three. It's Kim Jonghyun singing a solo ballad which happens to be a modern masterpiece accompanied with beautiful vocals.
This song is beautifully layered, it's like a towered cake of musical genius. You can also tell that Jonghyun put his all into recording this, the raw amount of emotion makes it something that I would really want to see live, because the studio version is amazing and I still don't think it does him justice.
The guitar solo damn near made me cry, the violins are just perfect, they're never too pitchy, nor are they too loud or obtrusive, they fit perfectly with the beat. Jonghyun was never too self-indulgent with his vocals and carried the right amount of emotion and technical skill to pull this off.
This song is literally brilliance! ^_^
There's just one problem...
TOO MUCH FUCKING REVERB ON THE VOCALS!!
WE GET IT, IT'S AN EMOTIONAL BALLAD...
YOU DON'T HAVE TO SLIDE THE SETTING FOR THE FUCKING REVERB VST ALL THE WAY TO A GAZILLION TO GET THAT MESSAGE ACROSS!!!
Geez... It almost ruined the song for me, because that is something I despise, when there is way too much reverb on the vocals, it is never flattering... But it still doesn't detract away from how beautiful this song is.
Overall (9/10) because I could never give full marks for something that was way too much reverb.
Four Seasons
*insert ballad joke here*
But in all seriousness, this is becoming a problem... Though it might be partially due to the fact that this is a repackage that includes most of the ballads from the EP and the old album, so I think I've finally answered my own question.
But again this isn't a bad song, it just so happens to be another ballad added to a growing list of ballads, but I think this one captures a bit more of my attention because of the fact that it has a nostalgic vibe of those early 90s songs that are so popular with the ladies in Britain (Westlife's entire discography anyone?).
The hard synths are present but never overbearing and the pads really put you in a different atmosphere, it's like trance-hop or something, I couldn't put it into a correct genre for you if I tried. The production value is more imaginative and somewhat avant-garde than what is the norm with most SM songs, but it does have a sense of structure so it isn't completely chaotic, but it's experimental enough to whet my musical appetite for a couple of minutes (or however long this song actually is...).
There is just one problem, one small, insignificant, yet consistent problem...
MINHO'S FUCKING RAPPING, GODDAMNIT WHY!!!
But hey, it wouldn't be SHINee if there wasn't an awkwardly delivered rap by the son of the Korean National Football team's coach. Choi freaking Minho ladies and gentlemen!
All in all, not bad, rather experimental as well (which is always a plus), but it really is too much like album filler for me to take it seriously... (8/10)
In My Room
Is there some inside joke I'm missing? This album has more freaking ballads in it than SM The Ballad Vol. 1...
If it helps the cause though, this song isn't bad at all, it's pretty good. But that would probably be all I have to say about it...
I've heard this guitar riff in too many of the songs on this album and the drum pattern is too similar to some of the other songs too, just because it is a ballad, it doesn't mean you have to be lazy about it.
The vocals are legitimately well-layered and the harmonies make it worth listening to as well, but overall it's just album filler again, and having too much album filler on one album (well having any at all doesn't make any sense to me, but I digress...) will depreciate the value of the album in its entirety, therefore you need to avoid having so much of these on this album, regardless of whether or not it is a repackage.
Overall, this isn't a bad track, but it is just so unfortunately placed after a non-stop bombardment of ballads in a poorly organized album, that I just can't take it seriously enough to give it any credit. Perhaps if it was a standalone song or on another album, it would have a higher rating, but for now?
(7/10)
The Shinee World
FINALLY, NO MORE BALLADS-- Oh wait, this is the end of the album?
... Doesn't matter it goes out with a bang!
I don't know if I'm happy because this song is an oasis of upbeat music after a drought where there has been nothing to ingest but bone-dry ballads (of which some of them were quite tasty), but this song put a smile on my face!
The beat is awesome, the synths are hard-hitting enough to leave an impact on the ears that makes you want to listen, the kick is sexy and the bass is doing the song justice, all-in-all this song wants to make you dance and you will dance!
Jonghyun comes to life in this song (even if his ballad voice is amazing, he just brings something new to the table with this song) and Key is meant for this type of song, even if it is an unpopular opinion, I don't think his voice is right for ballads and I've always seen him as someone good for upbeat songs like this one.
You want to know who is good for ballads? Lee Jinki Onew.
The piano and the pads during the bridge as well give a soft vibe that cools the song down, but at the same time makes you wary of the eventual breakdown that will happen after. AND BOY DOES THAT BREAKDOWN GO IN HARD!!!
It's like Dubba Jonny (think Skrillex only a million times better) has taken the song from SM studios and decided to just randomly add some epic ass synth breakdown that is only a couple of bars long but epic enough to make you rewind at least 40 times just to hear it again, and I speak from experience.
One problem? The hook... Where is it?
I could be wrong, but I'm sure that this was either released as a title track or a digital single, but regardless of that, this song needs a hook and I can't find it anywhere!
I would blame it on how the song is structured, but the song seems to be structured fine, it's just that lyrically it's all a bit jumbled, and quite frankly that's a shame and a waste of a perfectly good beat.
Oh and another problem is Minho's rapping again, but I've gotten accustomed to it being awful, so hey...
Overall? (9/10)
Average Track Rating: (7.9/10)
Album Rating: (8/10)
It's a good album in most parts and if you are a fan of ballads, you will cherish it always... But for someone who is a ballad sympathizer at best, it's not my cup of tea.
Granted there are some songs that made my non-existent ovaries burst and shout "Jjong-oppa! Saranghae!" at the top of my lungs (not that I'm biased towards Jonghyun or anything... This is a completely professional review!).
However, those songs are overshadowed by the fact that this album was poorly arranged, or maybe even brilliantly arranged because if "The Shinee World" was on earlier during the album (like say after Hyeya) I might not have liked it as much... If that is the case, then we have someone to replace Eduard Khil and Christopher Poole as the king and kami-sama of all trolls respectively, LEE SOOMAN!!!
You will enjoy this album regardless, because the songs are good and this is SHINee we are talking about... Who doesn't enjoy their work? XD